Five Big Tax Blunders for S Corporations

According to the Internal Revenue Service, S corporations now outnumber regular corporations and more than 350,000 new S corporations appear each year.

The popularity of Subchapter S corporations shouldn't really surprise people, however. S corporations provide two big tax savings to small business owners. First, they typically don't pay federal or state corporate income taxes.

And, second, S corporations often minimize the payroll taxes that S corporation shareholder-employees pay because only amounts the corporation designates as wages get taxed for Social Security and Medicare tax purposes. Unfortunately, S corporation owners make some common tax blunders–blunders that can destroy or delay the tax savings the S corporation option should deliver.

Blunder 1: Late Sub S Elections

The first blunder? Thinking you can make the S election at the end of the year. An S election needs to be made early in the year or before the year even starts in order to be effective for the year. Specifically, you should make the S election either before the year starts or within 75 days after the start of the new year.

For a business whose tax year begins on January 1, the election needs to be made by March 15. If a new business begins life mid-year on, say, May 23, the 75-day counter starts ticking down from that date.

Note: The IRS does provide a mulligan for people who miss the election deadline. Taking this mulligan, however, requires that you strictly follow some "late S election relief" procedures. Accordingly, you probably want to get a CPA's help with this.

Blunder 2: Forgetting Shareholder-employee Payroll

When you make a successful S election, the Internal Revenue Service sends your business an approval letter. That letter uses scary–almost threatening language–warning you to pay reasonable compensation to shareholder-employees.

Despite the warning, S corporations commonly forget to do the formal payroll thing–including regular payroll checks and tax deposits, quarterly payroll tax returns, and year-end W-2s. That's often a huge mistake.

If you don't do payroll, the IRS will catch up with you. At that point, the IRS will re-categorize all of the shareholder-employee draws as wages. This re-categorization may trigger thousands of dollars of back taxes, penalties and interest for each year and for each shareholder-employee for whom you forgot to do payroll.

Accordingly, you got to do payroll. Period.

Blunder 3: Bad Borrowing Habits

Ironically, your bank often helps you make another common S corporation tax blunder: The bank will loan you money to buy some piece of equipment–or perhaps a business vehicle.

But the bank often lends its money directly to your S corporation. As crazy as it sounds, the bank should loan the money to you personally and then you should loan the money to the S corp.

An awkward problem exists when a business loan gets used to fund an S corporation purchase. You get to write off your purchase only when you have at least that much basis in the S corporation. Yet you get basis only from money you've personally invested or loaned to the S corp.

You don't get basis from a loan made to your S corporation for, say, a new delivery vehicle purchased for the business. Without basis, you often won't be able to deduct the purchase on your tax return.

This S corporation tax mistake gets made all the time–often when S corporation owners are making last minute, year-end asset purchases to drive down their income.

Fortunately, you can solve the problem pretty easily. Make sure you directly borrow the money for asset purchases and then do a back-to-back loan to your corporation.

This back-to-back loan shouldn't increase your risks. You'll probably have to personally guarantee the loan anyway, right?

Blunder 4: Triggering the BIG Tax

Typically, S corporations don't pay federal income taxes. That's a huge part of the attraction. However, two common exceptions to this general rule exist for S corporations previously operated as regular C corporations.

The first exception? The "built-in gain" or BIG tax. It applies to profits recognized by the S corporation but stemming from the time when the corporation operated as a C corporation.

The details of the built-in gain tax get boringly tedious. But logic is really simple. If you would have paid tax on some income or gain had you still been a regular C corporation and that income or gain was already "locked in" at the point you converted from a C corporation to an S corporation, the old C corporation tax (35% of profits) still applies.

The moral: You need to be really careful if you convert to S corp status after operating as a C corporation. Make sure your accountant understands and helps you minimize the BIG tax.

Blunder 5: Passive Income Excesses

Another tax blunder threatens S corporations previously operated as C corporations, too.

If an S corporation profitably operated as a C corporation and has retained some of those profits, passive income (interest, rents, dividends and so forth) gets taxed when it exceeds 25% of gross receipts.

This "too much passive income" problem may sound only theoretical. But it occurs regularly with old S corporations being wound down by the owners–say for retirement.

If an S corporation that used to be a C corporation metamorphoses from an operating company to an investment company, at some point, the S corporation may pay corporate income taxes.

If that isn't bad enough, yet another problem exists with turning an S corporation that used to be a C corporation into an investment holding company. If the passive income crosses over the 25% threshold for three years in a row, the S corporation status terminates.

Because of the taxes on excessive passive income and the risk of losing S status, avoid or minimize passive income within an S corporation that previously operated as a C corporation. One easy way to do this is to distribute profits to shareholders rather than reinvest them.

About the Author

Seattle tax accountant Steve Nelson taught the S corporation vs LLC tax class in Golden Gate University's masters in tax program. Nelson is also the editor of the http://www.scorporationsexplained.com and http://www.llcsexplained.com web sites.

For All of your GOING PUBLIC needs visit our sister site Artfield Investments RD Inc. (www.ArtfieldInvestmentsRDinc.info)

This entry was posted in Corporations, Subchapter S. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply